#10, RE: The hard part
Posted by BeardedFerret on Jul-14-13 at 10:58 PM
In response to message #9
>>>Second person? The Crappy Internet Porn voice? I'm going to >>>have to decline. :) >> >>The... What? > >Second person - you did this, you did that, you experienced the other. > The only things I've ever seen written primarily in the second person >are particularly awful Internet porn stories and Charles Stross's >Halting State, which is like Internet porn without the porn. :) > >I don't recall a Sherlock Holmes story written in that format, but >then I haven't read the canon in a while. Most Holmes stories are in >the first person, but mainly telling about the actions of a third >party (as opposed to, say, Raymond Chandler's Philip Marlowe novels, >which are in the first person and mainly concerned with the narrating >character's own doings). Ah. There's the misunderstanding, then - I was given to understand that second person referred to fixed third person from the perspective of someone other than the protagonist - Watson observing Holmes, for example. A quick rifle through Wikipedia shows me that I - and by extension, my grade 4 teacher - were wrong about that. Having learned that, the only use I'd have for second person would be in text adventures. I was actually suggesting a fixed third person account.
|