|
Eyrie Productions, Unlimited
Perko
Charter Member
|
May-02-01, 11:28 AM (EDT) |
|
"Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
|
I'm very curious: people seemed to love NGE and Lain. I hated them both, mostly for the same reasons that I hear other people liked them. However, I'm curious to know: do people who like NGE tend to like Lain, or not? -Craig Need something to read? http://www.wpi.edu/~perko |
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
TRB
Member since Jan-4-21
|
May-02-01, 02:41 PM (EDT) |
|
1. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #0
|
I was mostly intrigued by NGE and it's pure fucked-up-ed-ness. It was the staring-at-the-train-wreck effect. Then NXE came along and showed me it was possible to make something out of that premise... ^__^ I found Lain to be slow paced and boring, so much so that I walked out of it at a con. I never walk out on anime at a con. I gave Lain every chance, it never moved. I guess we float in the same boat B-) Chalk up one for your column, heh heh.TRB "I wish I was reaper, culling lost souls. I wish I could cast them into deep and lonely holes." |
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
Gryphon
Charter Member
22420 posts |
May-02-01, 07:25 PM (EDT) |
|
2. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #0
|
>However, I'm curious to know: do people who like NGE tend to like >Lain, or not? I've only seen occasional fragmentary scenes from Lain, at times when it's been on while I went through the living room and the like. Certainly not enough to count as having watched it. So I guess I can't vote on this. I do like the title character's design, though, not that that has any bearing on anything. --G. -><- Benjamin D. Hutchins, Co-Founder, Editor in Chief, Netadmin Eyrie Productions, Unlimited http://www.eyrie-productions.com/
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
BobSchroeck
Charter Member
2258 posts |
May-03-01, 08:26 AM (EDT) |
|
3. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #0
|
>However, I'm curious to know: do people who like NGE tend to like >Lain, or not? My wife and I eagerly bought the Lain videotapes as they were released; and we've since enjoyed rewatching the series. We're also enjoying NGE on DVD as it comes out -- although I've been hiding most of what I know about the ending from her. She may hate it when it's done. Hell, *I* may hate it when it's done, judging from what I've heard. -- Bob
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
rugle
Charter Member
|
May-03-01, 09:46 PM (EDT) |
|
4. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #0
|
>I'm very curious: people seemed to love NGE and Lain. >I hated them both, mostly for the same reasons that >I hear other people liked them. >However, I'm curious to know: do people who like NGE tend >to like Lain, or not? lain, key and cowboy bebop are three shows i'm really glad to have seen. much more so than eva. my opinion of eva changed over time from enjoying it for being the best show i'd ever seen (because it was the first anime i'd ever seen since robotech when i was eight). there was great characterisation, and what may have been the most detailed anime project design ever, but when i stopped loving it for being a cool mecha story (it wasn't really) i started loving the way it pretended to be things that it wasn't, and pulled it off so well while you were watching. on the hostility thread Gryph mentioned that he disliked it as Anno used it to foist off his neuroses onto the audience; i hated this too (i don't need *more* neuroses), but i really, really admired the fact that he managed to do it in secret. it made eva a tragedy in as real a sense as i can describe - it started off looking like it was something good and pure, and the characters tear themselves apart by their own good intentions. it's not hamlet, but it's cool. there's a book called Foccault's Pendulum, which is half of why i love lain (and about a third of why i love utena ^_-). it's a novel about secrets and secret societies, and specifically the Knights of the Templar. lain managed to be sad, a little dark, and uplifting. it was a challenge to follow (which i like), and the plot essentially worked backwards - very little was revealed, but you could work out a hell of a lot in reverse (the bear suit was a good example). sure it seemed slow, but the content wasn't action. key was just brilliant. it was a little sad at the end, but it has to be one of the best robot shows i've ever seen, as well as one of the best mixes of character-driven and event-driven plots. then again, key, lain, rei .. is this some underlying trend in my watching? although ed doesn't follow suit, so i guess it isn't. cheers, .rugle "i'm sailor nothing .. and i'm very tired" -- himei, SN
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
|
megazone
Charter Member
|
May-03-01, 10:01 PM (EDT) |
|
5. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #4
|
>there's a book called Foccault's Pendulum, which is half of why By Umberto Eco - he also wrote The Name of the Rose. Both fantastic books. I have a 3rd book by him that I never got around to reading... Travels in Hyperreality I think - nonfiction, essays. >secrets and secret societies, and specifically the Knights of the >Templar. Actually that's just "Knights Templar". BTW, have you ever read anything by Robert Anton Wilson? Most famous for his fiction - he coauthored The Illuminatus! Trilogy, wrote The Schroedinger's Cat Trilogy, etc, but he has a number of non-fiction books too. He's one of my favorites. -MegaZone, megazone@megazone.org Personal Homepage http://www.megazone.org/ Eyrie Productions FanFic http://www.eyrie-productions.com/ |
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
|
|
Laudre
Charter Member
|
May-03-01, 10:23 PM (EDT) |
|
6. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #5
|
>BTW, have you ever read anything by Robert Anton Wilson? Most famous >for his fiction - he coauthored The Illuminatus! Trilogy,I loved the Illuminatus! Trilogy, but I discovered that the only way I could describe it to a friend was to tell him that it was kind of like James Joyce fucked Charles Fort and the baby dropped acid all the time while listening to Timothy Leary. > wrote The >Schroedinger's Cat Trilogy, I've always meant to read this; it's on the list of books that I should read but haven't yet. -- Sean -- http://www.thebrokenlink.org The Broken Link 4.0 is live! "Imagination is more important than knowledge." -- Albert Einstein "It's not easy being green." -- Kermit the Frog |
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Laudre
Charter Member
|
May-03-01, 11:11 PM (EDT) |
|
8. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #7
|
>>Timothy Leary. > ><div style="namedropping"> >I had a chat with Timothy Leary once over a beer. It's true. He was >really cool. ></div> Ummm... wow. I am truly in awe. -- Sean -- http://www.thebrokenlink.org The Broken Link 4.0 is live! "Imagination is more important than knowledge." -- Albert Einstein "It's not easy being green." -- Kermit the Frog |
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
|
|
rugle
Charter Member
|
May-03-01, 11:16 PM (EDT) |
|
9. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #5
|
>By Umberto Eco - he also wrote The Name of the Rose. ah! i should have guessed you'd know it ^_^ >Both fantastic books. yeah. i loved them both, although i spoiled TNOTR for myself by reading it when i was too young. both remain two of my favourite books though. >I have a 3rd book by him that I never got around to reading... >Travels in Hyperreality I think - nonfiction, essays. How To Travel With A Salmon was neat too .. >Actually that's just "Knights Templar". hmm? you're probably right there - i could be confusing it with the KCMG. or maybe just with lain's Knights of the Eastern Calculus, which was the link in lain that reminded me of FP in the first place. >BTW, have you ever read anything by Robert Anton Wilson? Most famous >for his fiction - he coauthored The Illuminatus! Trilogy, wrote The >Schroedinger's Cat Trilogy, etc, but he has a number of non-fiction >books too. He's one of my favorites. nope. although now, i just may. thanks. .rugle "if there is a plan, then it must involve everything" -- diotevelli (not content with possible misquoting, i may have mispelled his name too. damn) |
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
|
|
Gryphon
Charter Member
22420 posts |
May-03-01, 11:20 PM (EDT) |
|
10. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #9
|
>hmm? you're probably right there - i could be confusing it >with the KCMG. or maybe just with lain's Knights of the Eastern >Calculus, which was the link in lain that reminded me of FP in >the first place. The "Knights of the Eastern Calculus"? As opposed to the Knights of the Lambda Calculus? (btw, I think the Templars had a longer name, the Knights of the Temple of Saint So-and-So of Jerusalem or some such, but I've long since forgotten it.) --G. -><- Benjamin D. Hutchins, Co-Founder, Editor in Chief, Netadmin Eyrie Productions, Unlimited http://www.eyrie-productions.com/
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
|
|
rugle
Charter Member
|
May-04-01, 00:33 AM (EDT) |
|
11. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #10
|
>The "Knights of the Eastern Calculus"? >As opposed to the Knights of the Lambda Calculus?:grins: they've probably been around longer than lain has, and they sound terribly like the Knights in Serial Experiments : Lain. the Knights of the Eastern Calculus are a meta-group that turn up that exist only in the wired. the members' real lives are so diverse and un- conspiratorial it's almost sinister itself. lain also mentioned Xanadu and sported gratuituous overuse of imacs. the six second eyecatch with "think different" written in apple-garamond font during the last dvd was amusing. >(btw, I think the Templars had a longer name, the Knights of the >Temple of Saint So-and-So of Jerusalem or some such, but I've long >since forgotten it.) you mean i'm not just crazy and confused for sticking the 'of the' in there? gee, thanks. that just leaves craziness and confusion on a miriad of other topics :) and now i get to find out who or what Wolfwood is. life is good. .rugle "Eyebrows! I need Eyebrows!" -- FLCL
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
|
|
BobSchroeck
Charter Member
2258 posts |
May-04-01, 08:07 AM (EDT) |
|
12. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #4
|
>lain managed to be sad, a little dark, and uplifting. it was a challenge >to follow (which i like), and the plot essentially worked backwards - very >little was revealed, but you could work out a hell of a lot in reverse >(the bear suit was a good example). Okay, I didn't realize that there was something more to the bear suit. What did I miss? -- Bob
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
|
|
rugle
Charter Member
|
May-04-01, 08:50 AM (EDT) |
|
13. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #12
|
>Okay, I didn't realize that there was something more to the bear suit. >What did I miss? heh. much as i'd like to play this out and say that the bear suit was incredibly important to the plot, but i'm not that imaginative. the pajamas are one of the few things that give lain character besides her direct actions. there's not a lot of this as she doesn't really interact with the world much. it's the "lain of the real world". her room is full of bears. it's her. it's kind of like the power-lines. the hum of the power-lines are the presence of the wired. it's everywhere. just like the hum of the power-lines is changed in the final episodes, you don't see the bears in the wired until the final episode, because until that point the "lain of the wired" and the "lain of the real world" are very different people. sort of. it means more than i can give it credit for, but i really didn't mean all of that when i brought it up. i was just musing to myself that i didn't realise that they were pajamas when she wore them the first time and i kept wondering what the bear suit was for. later though it makes sense because later you see her sleeping in them. it's not that important really. i did like lain though. i did really like lain. .rugle "go .. somewhere where there are no power lines or telephones" -- tachibana (lain)
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
|
|
Perko
Charter Member
|
May-05-01, 01:41 AM (EDT) |
|
14. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #13
|
Groan... ah, the move 'home' from college. My dorm room's ten base-T, Sweet surfing liberty, of thee I sing! Sorry. Now, on to actual subject matter: Since you poor fellows have diluted my beautiful, pure stream of votes (I got, what, four?) with why you -liked- Lain and Eva, I guess I should rant about why I hate it (short rant, I promise!) Eva I hated because of it's characters. But, it was looking up. Everything was building to a scene where Shinji would save the day! Snurf, no dice. makes the whole series frikkin useless, and those 'human instrumentality' scenes at the end seemed awfully tacked on, as if to apologize for not explaining the Angels sufficiently. As for Lain, I hated the way it was vague and uninformative for the sake of being vague and uninformative (I think someone said this better in another post in another forum... about another series, maybe?). The person who made Lain obviously looked very closely at the market and said, 'the people of Japan would really love a good bizarre mystery thing' and, taking advantage of the sudden surge in popular strangeness, made Lain, the ultimate success in writing for your market, but ultimately empty. I especially liked how when they finally established Lain as a character, they tossed her personality away and replaced it at least once. Phoo, I liked Foucault's Pendulum - although similar on the surface, it not only had a more intelligent and clever exploration of events, it also had a good, solid twisted ending, as opposed to Lain, which I predicted starting from the second DVD. On the other hand, the Illuminatus Trilogy is only good to read if you want to simply sit through chaos and come out the other end with brain fodder for stranger dreams. Those whole ressurected waterlogged Nazi zombies made the book worth reading... but not if you're in the mood for an actual story. Lastly, Red Dwarf played today on the British channel for about three hours, and one of the episodes is when they explain exactly how JFK was assassinated, and who the mysterious man behind the grassy knoll was. It was extremely funny, despite my general ignorance in theories about said event (I'm a -story- buff, not a -paranoia- buff...) Okay, sorry for that long rant. I just think it's interesting that I can agree with so many people on so many things, but then they love some series I can't stand (Like you, Glenn! And Paul, if he reads this! You have NO TASTE!). I was just curious to see if there was a connection between why people liked EVA and Lain and why I disliked them... I guess not, but I'll tell you my criteria; Neither Lain nor EVA, in my opinion, were written to be stories. One was written to be a soulless, highly successful media phenominon and the other was written as a form of self psychology, at least in the end. I guess it's just me that notices these perhaps imagined things. -Craig Need something to read? http://www.wpi.edu/~perko Updated daily now that finals are over! |
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
|
|
rugle
Charter Member
|
May-05-01, 04:13 AM (EDT) |
|
15. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #14
|
>Since you poor fellows have diluted my beautiful, pure stream of votes >(I got, what, four?) with why you -liked- Lain and Eva, I guess I >should rant about why I hate it (short rant, I promise!) :grin: It *is* a forum, not a survey >established Lain as a character, they tossed her personality away and >replaced it at least once. I liked Lain the series, and the character. The way she acted in the wired was a part of who she was, just seldom used; the way other people saw her in the wired was just bizarre and really not her at all. That's why I like the bear suit so much - it showed that she *hadn't* been replaced, no matter how others kept seeing her. While there was the bear suit, there was the original Lain. >Phoo, I liked Foucault's Pendulum - although similar on the surface, >it not only had a more intelligent and clever exploration of events, >it also had a good, solid twisted ending, as opposed to Lain, which I >predicted starting from the second DVD. I can't say I predicted Lain, but it was different from FP. I just liked the similarity between both sets of Knights. >they explain exactly how JFK was assassinated, and who the mysterious I liked the Ace Rimmer one after it, myself. The look on the two German's faces after they get beaned with the crocodile was a classic >connection between why people liked EVA and Lain and why I disliked >them... I guess not, but I'll tell you my criteria; Has anyone else seen Key - The Metal Idol? If so, and you didn't really like Eva and Lain, did you prefer Key? >Neither Lain nor EVA, in my opinion, were written to be stories. One Eva more so than Lain. Lain had a very clever story - but it wasn't so much about Lain finding herself, as Lain trying not to lose Alice. I have this strange fixation on stories. When you write a story, you should give people something to aspire to, not just feel 'good' about. If people want to feel good, then there're many other things that they can do to be satisfied. A story should show them something desirable in themselves. I hated 'seven', for the same reasons Eva annoyed me - there was nothing redeeming about anything I saw there. A tragedy needs Catharsis. >end. I guess it's just me that notices these perhaps imagined things. Nup. I took Eva embarrassingly seriously for way too long. But don't go slappin' cut on da lain ^_^ .ruguel "not another fricking angel?!" -- friend, after rugle's typo
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
|
|
Wedge
Charter Member
|
May-05-01, 06:25 AM (EDT) |
|
16. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #15
|
>in themselves. I hated 'seven', for the same reasons Eva annoyed me - >there was nothing redeeming about anything I saw there. A tragedy >needs Catharsis. I would argue that Somerset was redeemed at the end of Seven in that Mills' 'destruction' caused him to rethink why he was retireing, and possibly causing him to gain back some of the more noble reasons for why he did the job in the first place, although part of that is inferred and not directly stated. The catharsis in the film is his. Admittedly, it's a little bit of redemption for a whole boatload of pain and suffering, but I still see it as being there. Keep in mind as well that I'm a confirmed David Fincher fan, and my comments are tainted as such. :) ------------------------------ "You're a louse, Roger Smith." ------------------------------ Chad Collier Digital Bitch J. Random VFX Company |
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
|
|
rugle
Charter Member
|
May-05-01, 07:16 AM (EDT) |
|
17. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #16
|
>that Mills' 'destruction' caused him to rethink why he was >retireing, and possibly causing him to gain back some of >the more noble reasons for why he did the job in the first >place, although part of that is wow. i never thought of it like that. i just put it down to compassion on his part for his partner. but you're right on both points - it's definitely catharsis of a sort, but it's not enough to make me feel good about watching it. thanks though. you've made that couple of hours of my life marginally less of a waste of time ^_^ .rugle "in the moment after the picture was taken .. the building didn't fall" -- tataki
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
|
|
Perko
Charter Member
|
May-05-01, 10:47 AM (EDT) |
|
18. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #15
|
Ah, there are several anime series which are of note due to strange phenomina. Gatekeepers had the piano-playing mecha, and Key had the robot singing songs which sucked people's souls out (okay, so it's not precisely right. Close enough for government work). I liked Key and Gatekeepers up until the 'end'. No, they have no similarities at all to each other, not even on the surface, except that their 'endings' really weren't. I hear there's a Key movie I have to watch for the real ending, while Gatekeepers' 'ending' -was- the last episode, and extremely irritating due to insufficient character development (ooh, look, ten characters with actual emotions and pasts that we've spent all this time developing! Let's completely ignore them!) -Craig Need something to read? http://www.wpi.edu/~perko |
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
|
|
rugle
Charter Member
|
May-05-01, 07:27 PM (EDT) |
|
20. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #18
|
LAST EDITED ON May-05-01 AT 07:51 PM (EDT) >that their 'endings' really weren't. I hear there's a Key movie I have
Key had thirteen episodes and two movie-length episodes. The first movie-length episode was something of an explanation (cue Ms Fresnjue) which turned a lot of people off because it consisted mainly of people narrating. I didn't mind this because the story held me the whole way. There is a lot you can only find out in that episode. The last movie rocked. It was sad, it was happy, it was uplifting, and most of all, I kept wondering how much of the Third Impact scene was affected by it. Key was apparently a very powerful show for its time, and its influence seems to have showed up in both Eva and Lain. If you haven't seen the two movie-length episodes, you've really missed out. You've even missed out on the full length version of In The Night which is shown at the beginning of the second movie. It's still one of my favourite songs (does that intro. remind anyone else of that bg music from the Matrix that never made the soundtrack?) .rugle "It read: Beryl, just borrowing your generals for a bit ^_^ signed Genaku McTome." -- Insertion (Carrotglace)
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
|
|
rugle
Charter Member
|
May-05-01, 07:43 PM (EDT) |
|
21. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #18
|
LAST EDITED ON May-05-01 AT 07:47 PM (EDT) > phenomina. Gatekeepers had the piano-playing mecha, and Only blink can I, seeing have not I seen, of this show, this much. .rugle "rooftop ethernet was obviously the go" -- describing Cafe Le Net
|
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
|
Mephron
Charter Member
1896 posts |
May-05-01, 01:52 PM (EDT) |
|
19. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #0
|
I enjoyed Lain. I also have a regular discussion with someone about what it 'means'. I'm lending the entire thing tomorrow to an associate of mine who was going for his Doctorate in English Literature until such time as he found that he couldn't actually afford most of it. He's the kind of person that started pulling 'tributes' to Batman AND Flash Gordon in Big O (his current pet theory is that Paradigm City is all a plot by Mongo to figure out how to beat Earth in another war, and Angel is the daughter of the King of the Hawk-Men). I expect that Lain will either reduce his synapses to a thin fluid or make him take his deconstructionism somewhere else..... (I find it highly amusing that Lain, Big O and Digimon all have the same core creator...) -- Geoff Depew - Mephron "Big O! Showtime!" |
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
FnordChan
Member since Nov-14-16
8 posts |
May-09-01, 06:18 PM (EDT) |
|
22. "RE: Headcount: Fans of Anime I Hate"
In response to message #0
|
I really enjoyed Lain for a variety of reasons. At it's core, I think Lain is the best cyberpunk anime to come down the pike, period. Sure, we're not exactly talking chrome and mirrorshades here, but that's what makes Lain so refreshing. It manages to get away from many of the horribly overdone cyberpunk cliches and still maintain many of the concepts and sheer style that defined cyberpunk as an early literary movement. Ghost in the Shell bored me; Lain kept me enthralled. If nothing else, Lain wins bonus points for it's background concepts. When Ted Nelson got name dropped in one of the later episodes, I almost fell out of my chair. Finally, I love the subdued, melancholy atmosophere that surrounds Lain. For whatever reason, Lain pushed a lot of my buttons. Eva, on the other hand, was very disappointing. I felt the television series was absolutely fantastic for the first 13 or so episodes. Then, for whatever reason, things went straight to hell. First off, Eva manages to completely derail in terms of animation. Oh, look - recycled footage. Oh, look - it's a static shot of an elevator. Oh, look - it's a static shot of Eva-01 waiting for Beethoven's Ninth to peak before squishing someone. Oh, look - kanji and peole sitting in chairs. Part of the reason I like anime is because I like animation in general, and by the end of Eva that just ain't happening. Then, Eva proceeds to fail as science fiction. If anyone ever offered a clear explanation of why Angels - whatever they were - are attacking Earth, I never picked up on it. (Of course, I was watching god awful fansubs, which didn't help). This isn't to say that a show needs to have it's concepts clearly explained to be enjoyable. However, I was disappointed that large portions of the plot got thrown out the window by the end of the series. As far as the end goes, I'll agree that Eva succeeds as a character study. Not a terribly exciting character study, mind you, but it works well enough. I'd have been a lot more impressed if Gainax (and particularly Anno) had managed to provide a satisfying plot resolution and solid animation to go along with the character study, but oh well. So, overall, by the end of it the Eva TV series just didn't do much for me. Which is rather sad, because looking at the first half Eva had the potential to be the Greatest Giant Robot Anime Series EVAR. Oh well. On the other hand, I positively loathe the End of Evangelion movie, but that's a topic for another discussion entirely. FnordChan -- "I do have a cause, though. It's obscenity. I'm for it." - Tom Lehrer |
|
|
Printer-friendly page | Top |
|
|
version 3.3 © 2001
Eyrie Productions,
Unlimited
Benjamin
D. Hutchins
E P U (Colour)
|