[ EPU Foyer ] [ Lab and Grill ] [ Bonus Theater!! ] [ Rhetorical Questions ] [ CSRANTronix ] [ GNDN ] [ Subterranean Vault ] [ Discussion Forum ] [ Gun of the Week ]

Eyrie Productions, Unlimited

Subject: "Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box"     Previous Topic | Next Topic
Printer-friendly copy    
Conferences Games Topic #125
Reading Topic #125, reply 23
MoonEyes
Member since Jun-29-03
1126 posts
Dec-10-17, 09:36 PM (EDT)
Click to EMail MoonEyes Click to send private message to MoonEyes Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list Click to send message via ICQ  
23. "RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box"
In response to message #18
 
   >Being a player character is a whole rigmarole. Unless they
>added one in the fourth or fifth editions, there is no "ordinary mook"
>character class in D&D; all adventurers, even first-level scrubs, are
>far better than the Common Folk at whatever they're doing. To that
>end, there are
>plenty of
>historical precedents
>involving melee weapons. They all require specialized training, but
>then, so does picking locks.

Well, sure, but there is a lot of difference between "better than ordinary folks" and "able to utilize a very rare and difficult combat method." And sure, there are two-sword methods, but they're, well, rare and difficult. Using a main-gauche is rather different than swinging two swords around, the dimachaerus trained long and hard and literally did nothing else, on the premise that dying in the arena would be bad, and Niten-Ichi is the single "formalized" form that I know of, ANYWHERE, that really does the two-sword thing. As best I know, there is nothing even remotely like it in any fecht-bucher.


>With guns, not so much, but for different reasons; with any ranged
>weapon, the typical human visual field only has one small field of
>foveal vision, and so can allow for only one point of aim. This is
>why fictional characters who can effectively dual-wield with
>simultaneous fire (as opposed to ambidexterous alternating fire)
>generally have some kind of shtick going on where they don't need to
>aim or even be able to see what they're shooting at (e.g., the gun
>kata in Equilibrium).

That being entirely my point, yes, about shooting.

In all honesty, unless you're essentially Japanese, who didn't do the whole shield-thing, as a personal bit of kit(there were Pavis-like ones, as I recall, but...) there is no reason what so ever to do two swords when a sword and a shield is much more efficient. Thus, "rule of cool" which, sure, it's a game, but all the same, it should require a bit more than "I bought two swords instead of one sword and a bow".

As noted, my opinion, worth what you pay for it, etcetera etcetera etcetera.

...!
Stoke Mandeville, Esq & The Victorian Ballsmiths
"Nobody Want Verdigris-Covered Balls!"


  Alert | IP Printer-friendly page | Edit | Reply | Reply With Quote | Top

  Subject     Author     Message Date     ID  
 Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box [View All] Gryphonadmin Dec-09-17 TOP
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box StClair Dec-10-17 1
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 2
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Dec-10-17 14
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box zwol Dec-10-17 17
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box rwpikul Dec-11-17 26
              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box zwol Dec-11-17 27
                  RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box rwpikul Dec-12-17 34
                      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-12-17 35
                          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Dec-12-17 36
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box jonathanlennox Dec-19-17 41
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Mephronmoderator Dec-19-17 40
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Wiregeek Dec-10-17 3
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-11-17 28
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Dec-11-17 29
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box drakensis Dec-10-17 4
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 12
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box drakensis Dec-11-17 25
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Mercutio Dec-10-17 5
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box MoonEyes Dec-10-17 6
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Mercutio Dec-10-17 7
              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 8
              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box MoonEyes Dec-10-17 13
                  RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Dec-10-17 16
                      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Trscroggs Jan-02-18 42
                          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Jan-02-18 43
                              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Jan-02-18 44
                              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Trscroggs Jan-02-18 45
                  RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 18
                     RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box MoonEyes Dec-10-17 23
                          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Nova Floresca Dec-11-17 32
                          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Silversword Dec-18-17 39
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 10
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Mercutio Dec-10-17 20
              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 21
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-13-17 37
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Proginoskes Dec-10-17 15
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box MoonEyes Dec-10-17 24
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box DaPatman89 Dec-10-17 9
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 11
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box StClair Dec-10-17 19
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box pjmoyermoderator Dec-10-17 22
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Kendra Kirai Dec-11-17 30
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Dec-11-17 31
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Kendra Kirai Dec-11-17 33
              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Jan-02-18 46
                  RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Kendra Kirai Jan-03-18 47
                  RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box MoonEyes Jan-03-18 48
                      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Jan-03-18 49
                          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Jan-03-18 51
                      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Jan-03-18 50
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box BobSchroeck Dec-18-17 38


Conferences | Topics | Previous Topic | Next Topic

[ YUM ] [ BIG ] [ ??!? ] [ RANT ] [ GNDN ] [ STORE ] [ FORUM ] GOTW ] [ VAULT ]

version 3.3 © 2001
Eyrie Productions, Unlimited
Benjamin D. Hutchins
E P U (Colour)