[ EPU Foyer ] [ Lab and Grill ] [ Bonus Theater!! ] [ Rhetorical Questions ] [ CSRANTronix ] [ GNDN ] [ Subterranean Vault ] [ Discussion Forum ] [ Gun of the Week ]

Eyrie Productions, Unlimited

Subject: "Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box"     Previous Topic | Next Topic
Printer-friendly copy    
Conferences Games Topic #125
Reading Topic #125, reply 32
Nova Floresca
Member since Sep-13-13
568 posts
Dec-11-17, 05:25 PM (EDT)
Click to EMail Nova%20Floresca Click to send private message to Nova%20Floresca Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
32. "RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box"
In response to message #23
 
   >In all honesty, unless you're essentially Japanese, who didn't do the
>whole shield-thing, as a personal bit of kit(there were Pavis-like
>ones, as I recall, but...) there is no reason what so ever to do two
>swords when a sword and a shield is much more efficient. Thus, "rule
>of cool" which, sure, it's a game, but all the same, it should require
>a bit more than "I bought two swords instead of one sword and a bow".

As a counterpoint, while yes sword + shield is more efficient than two swords in most cases, the list of cases where the two swords could prove to be more useful and the list of situations a party of D&D adventurers might get into overlap quite well. For one, there's the clockwise stairs problem in castles, which would make being ambidextrous an advantage.

Second, the name of the game is Dungeons and Dragons, and their definition of "Dungeons" is pretty much "old, decrepit, hazardous, and underground". A large shield is going to be your worst enemy when trying to clamber around obstacles in such an environment.

Lastly, yes, anyone can wield two weapons just by picking up two blades- at a hideous penalty. It takes a substantial investment of training (in the form of feats) to be any good at it. A 2nd-level Wizard can spray fire from his hands, strike down distant foes with homing darts of force, and give a man the size and strength of an ogre. A 2nd-level Cleric can call upon the blessings of his deity to heal wounds, withstand the blazing heat of a desert, and understand any spoken or written word with perfect clarity. A 2nd-level Fighter . . . can hone his skills to where he can swing two swords at the same time without them getting in each other's way too much, and even use the off-hand weapon to parry attacks.

"This is probably a stupid question, but . . ."


  Alert | IP Printer-friendly page | Edit | Reply | Reply With Quote | Top

  Subject     Author     Message Date     ID  
 Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box [View All] Gryphonadmin Dec-09-17 TOP
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box StClair Dec-10-17 1
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 2
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Dec-10-17 14
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box zwol Dec-10-17 17
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box rwpikul Dec-11-17 26
              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box zwol Dec-11-17 27
                  RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box rwpikul Dec-12-17 34
                      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-12-17 35
                          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Dec-12-17 36
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box jonathanlennox Dec-19-17 41
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Mephronmoderator Dec-19-17 40
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Wiregeek Dec-10-17 3
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-11-17 28
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Dec-11-17 29
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box drakensis Dec-10-17 4
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 12
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box drakensis Dec-11-17 25
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Mercutio Dec-10-17 5
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box MoonEyes Dec-10-17 6
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Mercutio Dec-10-17 7
              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 8
              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box MoonEyes Dec-10-17 13
                  RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Dec-10-17 16
                      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Trscroggs Jan-02-18 42
                          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Jan-02-18 43
                              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Jan-02-18 44
                              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Trscroggs Jan-02-18 45
                  RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 18
                      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box MoonEyes Dec-10-17 23
                         RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Nova Floresca Dec-11-17 32
                          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Silversword Dec-18-17 39
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 10
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Mercutio Dec-10-17 20
              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 21
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-13-17 37
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Proginoskes Dec-10-17 15
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box MoonEyes Dec-10-17 24
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box DaPatman89 Dec-10-17 9
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 11
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box StClair Dec-10-17 19
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box pjmoyermoderator Dec-10-17 22
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Kendra Kirai Dec-11-17 30
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Dec-11-17 31
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Kendra Kirai Dec-11-17 33
              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Jan-02-18 46
                  RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Kendra Kirai Jan-03-18 47
                  RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box MoonEyes Jan-03-18 48
                      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Jan-03-18 49
                          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Jan-03-18 51
                      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Jan-03-18 50
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box BobSchroeck Dec-18-17 38


Conferences | Topics | Previous Topic | Next Topic

[ YUM ] [ BIG ] [ ??!? ] [ RANT ] [ GNDN ] [ STORE ] [ FORUM ] GOTW ] [ VAULT ]

version 3.3 © 2001
Eyrie Productions, Unlimited
Benjamin D. Hutchins
E P U (Colour)