[ EPU Foyer ] [ Lab and Grill ] [ Bonus Theater!! ] [ Rhetorical Questions ] [ CSRANTronix ] [ GNDN ] [ Subterranean Vault ] [ Discussion Forum ] [ Gun of the Week ]

Eyrie Productions, Unlimited

Subject: "Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box"     Previous Topic | Next Topic
Printer-friendly copy    
Conferences Games Topic #125
Reading Topic #125, reply 39
Silversword
Member since Jan-4-05
80 posts
Dec-18-17, 11:31 PM (EDT)
Click to EMail Silversword Click to send private message to Silversword Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
39. "RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box"
In response to message #23
 
   >In all honesty, unless you're essentially Japanese, who didn't do the
>whole shield-thing, as a personal bit of kit(there were Pavis-like
>ones, as I recall, but...) there is no reason what so ever to do two
>swords when a sword and a shield is much more efficient. Thus, "rule
>of cool" which, sure, it's a game, but all the same, it should require
>a bit more than "I bought two swords instead of one sword and a bow".
>

So, I feel obligated to point out that China is a very big place with a lot of martial arts styles, and the exclusively dual-weilded butterfly swords are way more common than the shield in my experiance, and that's not even touching on all the other dual-weilded weapons in which I have none.

As for why you'd dual weild instead of using a shield, well, if you're excluding all the noncombat things like concealability, manouverability and redundancy (and you probably shouldn't - a shield's efficiency in combat is cumbersome in another), a pair of short weapons is remarkably effective against spears and poles, which are very common weapons. An offhand smallblade gives you a level of control over your opponent's weapons that a shield does not.

Granted, this does not make dual-weilding automatically superior or even practical in many cases, but remember that the shield is the tool of a soldier and is best employed in ranks, and a D&D group is generally not those things. Rule of cool may be a very big draw for a lot of people, but there wouldn't be dual-weild styles at all anywhere ever if it wasn't a practical thing in some capacity.


~Silv'


  Alert | IP Printer-friendly page | Edit | Reply | Reply With Quote | Top

  Subject     Author     Message Date     ID  
 Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box [View All] Gryphonadmin Dec-09-17 TOP
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box StClair Dec-10-17 1
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 2
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Dec-10-17 14
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box zwol Dec-10-17 17
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box rwpikul Dec-11-17 26
              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box zwol Dec-11-17 27
                  RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box rwpikul Dec-12-17 34
                      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-12-17 35
                          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Dec-12-17 36
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box jonathanlennox Dec-19-17 41
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Mephronmoderator Dec-19-17 40
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Wiregeek Dec-10-17 3
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-11-17 28
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Dec-11-17 29
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box drakensis Dec-10-17 4
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 12
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box drakensis Dec-11-17 25
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Mercutio Dec-10-17 5
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box MoonEyes Dec-10-17 6
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Mercutio Dec-10-17 7
              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 8
              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box MoonEyes Dec-10-17 13
                  RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Dec-10-17 16
                      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Trscroggs Jan-02-18 42
                          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Jan-02-18 43
                              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Jan-02-18 44
                              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Trscroggs Jan-02-18 45
                  RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 18
                      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box MoonEyes Dec-10-17 23
                          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Nova Floresca Dec-11-17 32
                         RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Silversword Dec-18-17 39
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 10
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Mercutio Dec-10-17 20
              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 21
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-13-17 37
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Proginoskes Dec-10-17 15
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box MoonEyes Dec-10-17 24
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box DaPatman89 Dec-10-17 9
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Dec-10-17 11
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box StClair Dec-10-17 19
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box pjmoyermoderator Dec-10-17 22
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Kendra Kirai Dec-11-17 30
      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Dec-11-17 31
          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Kendra Kirai Dec-11-17 33
              RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Jan-02-18 46
                  RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Kendra Kirai Jan-03-18 47
                  RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box MoonEyes Jan-03-18 48
                      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Jan-03-18 49
                          RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Gryphonadmin Jan-03-18 51
                      RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box Peter Eng Jan-03-18 50
   RE: Elder Days Story Time: The Red Box BobSchroeck Dec-18-17 38


Conferences | Topics | Previous Topic | Next Topic

[ YUM ] [ BIG ] [ ??!? ] [ RANT ] [ GNDN ] [ STORE ] [ FORUM ] GOTW ] [ VAULT ]

version 3.3 © 2001
Eyrie Productions, Unlimited
Benjamin D. Hutchins
E P U (Colour)