[ EPU Foyer ] [ Lab and Grill ] [ Bonus Theater!! ] [ Rhetorical Questions ] [ CSRANTronix ] [ GNDN ] [ Subterranean Vault ] [ Discussion Forum ] [ Gun of the Week ]

Eyrie Productions, Unlimited

Subject: "Galactipedia: Armorsport"     Previous Topic | Next Topic
Printer-friendly copy    
Conferences Featured Documents Topic #277
Reading Topic #277, reply 25
Mercutio
Member since May-26-13
941 posts
Aug-22-14, 07:29 PM (EDT)
Click to EMail Mercutio Click to send private message to Mercutio Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
25. "RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport"
In response to message #18
 
   >>>"Classic" Tankery, played under the original pre-Contact rules,
>>>permits only the use of AFVs designed and built on Earth before the
>>>surrender of Nazi Germany to end the European phase of that planet's
>>>Second World War, May 8, 1945. Some extremely strict forms of
>>>sensha-dō take that restriction even further and require that
>>>teams limit themselves only to equipment that would logically have
>>>been operated by one combatant force in that war (e.g., all Soviet
>>>equipment, all German, or mixed UK and US hardware), but that rule is
>>>considered archaic and optional even under the modern Co-Prosperity
>>>Sphere Ministry for Sport regulations.
>>
>>Given the combatants mentioned here -- and the cutoff date -- I take
>>it not even the Co-Prosperity Sphere's Tankers think that their
>>WW2-era's namesake's tanks are worth bothering with?
>
>Well, the list is not meant to be comprehensive, but in general, no.
>Not many survivors from the Pacific theater in any event. They didn't
>hold up so well. Humidity, you know.

... would that matter? The plans would still be available. You could get a lot of mileage out of surprising the enemy team with something that has a performance profile they're unfamiliar with even if the actual tank is mediocre.

Although I will note that I'm parsing "designed and built" as "you must use a tank design that was built prior to May 8th, 1945" rather than "you must use an actual hull that rolled off the assembly line prior to that date."

Because, I mean, the latter would basically ensure that that form of the sport eventually died out. Tanks wear out. They wear out fast. Especially once from that era. Treads alone probably need to be replaced after every single match, so that's already one major component you'd have to very quickly switch to using modern repros of. Eventually you'd have people rolling around in hulls in which every single major component (including, er, the hull) had been replaced with something machined well after 1945.

Would make more sense if everyone were using modern repros rather than actually things that were busting down hedgerows in the bocage.

-Merc
Keep Rat


  Alert | IP Printer-friendly page | Edit | Reply | Reply With Quote | Top

  Subject     Author     Message Date     ID  
 Galactipedia: Armorsport [View All] Gryphonadmin Aug-19-14 TOP
   RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport alange Aug-19-14 1
   RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Matrix Dragon Aug-19-14 2
   RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport drakensis Aug-19-14 3
      RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Gryphonadmin Aug-19-14 4
          RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport mdg1 Aug-19-14 6
          RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Arashi Aug-19-14 9
   RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Gryphonadmin Aug-19-14 5
   RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport BobSchroeck Aug-19-14 7
      RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Gryphonadmin Aug-19-14 8
   RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Bad Moon Aug-21-14 10
      RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Gryphonadmin Aug-21-14 11
          RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Nathan Aug-21-14 12
              RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Croaker May-01-17 48
          RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport mdg1 Aug-21-14 16
              RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Gryphonadmin Aug-21-14 17
                  RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Nova Floresca Aug-21-14 19
          RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Bad Moon Aug-22-14 20
              RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Gryphonadmin Aug-22-14 21
                  RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport mdg1 Aug-22-14 22
                      RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Terminus Est Aug-26-14 39
                          RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport TheOtherSean Aug-26-14 40
                              RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Terminus Est Aug-26-14 41
                                  RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Droken Aug-26-14 42
                                      RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Terminus Est Aug-27-14 43
                      RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Gryphonadmin Sep-04-14 44
                          RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Nova Floresca Sep-04-14 45
                              RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Gryphonadmin Sep-04-14 46
                                  RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Berk Nov-29-17 61
                  RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport laudre Aug-22-14 23
                      RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Gryphonadmin Aug-22-14 24
                          RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport laudre Aug-23-14 31
   RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport rwpikul Aug-21-14 13
      RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Gryphonadmin Aug-21-14 14
   RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport jonathanlennox Aug-21-14 15
      RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Gryphonadmin Aug-21-14 18
         RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Mercutio Aug-22-14 25
              RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport pjmoyermoderator Aug-22-14 26
                  RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Nova Floresca Aug-22-14 27
                      RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Gryphonadmin Aug-22-14 28
                      RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Mercutio Aug-22-14 29
                          RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Berrik Aug-23-14 30
                              RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport SpottedKitty Aug-23-14 32
                                  RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Gryphonadmin Aug-23-14 33
                                      RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport CdrMike Aug-23-14 34
                                          RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Nova Floresca Aug-23-14 35
                  RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport SneakyPete Aug-25-14 36
                      RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Gryphonadmin Aug-25-14 37
                          RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Bad Moon Aug-25-14 38
   RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport CdrMike Mar-27-17 47
   RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport trboturtle2 May-01-17 49
      RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Gryphonadmin May-01-17 50
          RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport CdrMike May-02-17 51
              RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Peter Eng May-02-17 52
                  RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport dbrandon May-02-17 53
   RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport NHO Jun-08-17 54
      RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Gryphonadmin Jun-08-17 55
          RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport NHO Jun-08-17 56
          RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport mdg1 Jun-10-17 57
              RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Kendra Kirai Jun-10-17 58
                  RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Peter Eng Jun-10-17 59
              RE: Galactipedia: Armorsport Gryphonadmin Jun-10-17 60


Conferences | Topics | Previous Topic | Next Topic

[ YUM ] [ BIG ] [ ??!? ] [ RANT ] [ GNDN ] [ STORE ] [ FORUM ] GOTW ] [ VAULT ]

version 3.3 © 2001
Eyrie Productions, Unlimited
Benjamin D. Hutchins
E P U (Colour)