[ EPU Foyer ] [ Lab and Grill ] [ Bonus Theater!! ] [ Rhetorical Questions ] [ CSRANTronix ] [ GNDN ] [ Subterranean Vault ] [ Discussion Forum ]

Eyrie Productions, Unlimited

Subject: "Space Battleship Wha?"     Previous Topic | Next Topic
Printer-friendly copy    
Conferences eyrie.private-mail Topic #652
Reading Topic #652
Gryphonadmin
Charter Member
17079 posts
Sep-09-15, 00:38 AM (EDT)
Click to EMail Gryphon Click to send private message to Gryphon Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
"Space Battleship Wha?"
 
   Since someone mentioned it in the Cantata for Warships thread, I just thought I would mention that - going straight back to the original Star Blazers dub I loved as a kid - the original Space Battleship Yamato premise has never actually made the slightest bit of sense to me. I simply can't stretch credulity far enough to encompass the idea that the best option, or even a viable option, for constructing a starship was to use the 254-year-old wreck of a twentieth-century battleship. I mean... what? Sure, I mean, if you have a character who is the god of mecha and he's not really paying as much attention as he should be to what he's doing, yeah, but in a straight-up sci-fi story?

I can kind of accept that the situation was desperate enough at that point that nobody really hesitated at the whole desecration-of-a-war-grave thing, but just from a practical standpoint, the whole idea is wack. I mean, all the other incomprehensible things about making a starship out of a sunken WWII battleship aside, there's not likely to be much left of the wreck by 2199.

Loved the show as a kid, respect it for its significance to the history of Japanese animation now, but... yeah. Makes no dang sense at all.

--G.
-><-
Benjamin D. Hutchins, Co-Founder, Editor-in-Chief, & Forum Mod
Eyrie Productions, Unlimited http://www.eyrie-productions.com/
zgryphon at that email service Google has
Ceterum censeo Carthaginem esse delendam.


  Alert | IP Printer-friendly page | Edit | Reply | Reply With Quote | Top
TheOtherSean
Member since Jul-7-08
189 posts
Sep-09-15, 01:35 AM (EDT)
Click to EMail TheOtherSean Click to send private message to TheOtherSean Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
1. "RE: Space Battleship Wha?"
In response to message #0
 
   Yep, makes no sense whatsoever. I've read a few novels involving contemporary humans getting access to advanced space propulsion and converting modern in-service submarines for space. In all cases it was an expediency move made immediately after acquiring the new technology and before purpose-built hulls could be designed and built. Like in Space Battleship Yamato/Star Blazers, it was a desperation situation, defending against alien invasion or scouting for where aliens who had attacked may be located. But it made sense as a temporary stopgap - pressure hull, life support, nuclear reactor aboard already, etc.

That is quite different from Yamato, which was a 150 year old sunken wreck of a surface vessel. Surely other preserved ships would be better candidates. Or leveraging existing submarine manufacturing facilities. It was awesome to watch as a little kid, and the relatively-recent live action movie was pretty cool.

--
The Other Sean - Don't accept substitutes!
Quis Custodiet Ipsos Custodes?


  Alert | IP Printer-friendly page | Edit | Reply | Reply With Quote | Top
Tabasco
Member since Dec-4-06
167 posts
Sep-09-15, 10:09 AM (EDT)
Click to EMail Tabasco Click to send private message to Tabasco Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
2. "RE: Space Battleship Wha?"
In response to message #0
 
   LAST EDITED ON Sep-09-15 AT 10:10 AM (EDT)
 
In fairness, the 2199 remake drops the idea like a hot rock. The Yamato looks like an old warship as camouflage, since it's construction site is near the graves of several of them.

--------------------
Space for Rent


  Alert | IP Printer-friendly page | Edit | Reply | Reply With Quote | Top

Conferences | Topics | Previous Topic | Next Topic

[ YUM ] [ BIG ] [ ??!? ] [ RANT ] [ GNDN ] [ STORE ] [ FORUM ] [ VAULT ]

version 3.3 © 2001
Eyrie Productions, Unlimited
Benjamin D. Hutchins
E P U (Colour)